November 19, 2026
Near Jettie Rae's Oyster House, on one corner of a 6.8-acre block off Charlotte Street, site work at Aster Court began this month. Up in Beaverdam Valley, the model home at The Villas at Pinecroft is open every Sunday from 1 to 4 p.m. Both are new for-sale townhome communities in North Asheville, and they share a builder: Asheville Watchdog reported that Amarx is the construction company behind Aster Court, and Amarx Communities is developing Pinecroft.
Aster Court's published price range is $980,000 to $1,100,000. Pinecroft starts at $499,900. The largest floor plan of the two belongs to Pinecroft. Mills Coin & Co. handles sales at Aster Court. Every figure below comes from the published project materials and public records for both communities, so the two can be compared on the same terms.
Every plan at Pinecroft has three bedrooms and two and a half baths. The Middle Unit is 1,446 square feet, the End Unit is 1,591 square feet and the Duplex plan is 2,125 square feet. Each comes with a single-car garage. On Aster Court's models page, the Phase 1 homes range from the four-bedroom Heath at 1,781 square feet to Calico and Showy plans between 1,857 and 1,892 square feet. Each has a private two-car garage.
Aster Court | The Villas at Pinecroft | |
|---|---|---|
Location | 223 E. Chestnut St., Chestnut Hill | Collin Place, Beaverdam Valley |
Published pricing | $980,000 to $1,100,000 | From $499,900 |
Plan sizes | 1,781 to 1,892 sq. ft. in Phase 1 | 1,446 to 2,125 sq. ft. |
Bedrooms | 3 to 4 | 3 |
Garage | Private two-car | Single-car |
Total homes | 18 | 41 |
Distance to downtown, per developer | 0.5 miles | 3.5 miles |
Divide price by square footage and the gap gets wider. Using Aster Court's published range and its Phase 1 plan sizes, the homes come to roughly $520 to $620 per square foot. At Pinecroft, the $499,900 starting price works out to about $346 per square foot on the smallest plan and about $235 on the largest. The Pinecroft Duplex plan is more than 200 square feet larger than any Phase 1 model at Aster Court.
The two-car garage, the whole-floor primary suites and the 9- to 10-foot ceilings account for part of the difference. Finishes and garages don't explain doubling the price per square foot, though. Most of the premium is for location.
Aster Court sits in the Chestnut Hills Historic District, half a mile from downtown. Its project page lists Jettie Rae's Oyster House, The Chop Shop Butchery, City Bakery, Mamacita's Taco Temple, Harris Teeter, Trader Joe's and Whole Foods among the places nearby. The surrounding streets have Colonial Revival, Queen Anne and Victorian houses from the 19th and 20th centuries, and the townhomes were designed to fit in with them.
Pinecroft's setting is a different kind of place. Amarx describes 41 townhomes on six acres with long-range mountain views. By the builder's figures, Beaver Lake is 2.5 miles away, Ingles and The Fresh Market are each 2.4 miles, the Blue Ridge Parkway is 2.8 miles and downtown is 3.5 miles. At Pinecroft the trade is more house and a short drive to the Parkway, while Aster Court puts dinner and groceries within a short walk.
For someone downsizing from a larger North Asheville house, a Pinecroft plan can match the floor space they're used to. An Aster Court home is mainly a purchase of location. The North Asheville neighborhood guide covers the established streets between these two locations.
The price premium at Aster Court partly reflects how little new for-sale housing has been built close to downtown. The Asheville Citizen Times wrote in December 2025 that in 2021, the corner of Charlotte Street and Chestnut Street had seemed ready for redevelopment, with proposals that included commercial space, townhomes and affordable apartments. Heading into 2026, the paper reported that one developer was pulling back because of rising costs. In June 2025, WLOS reported that a Charlotte Street corridor developer's conditional zoning had expired in October 2023 and that the former Ingles and Fuddruckers sites were still vacant. The plan the Citizen Times reported in 2024 for the Fuddruckers site was 186 affordable apartments.
Aster Court got much smaller before construction started. Asheville Watchdog reported that the original plan was a 211,000-square-foot mixed-use building with more than 180 residences. That plan became 18 townhomes on a corner of the block, away from Charlotte Street. The City issued the small-scale approval in September 2024. William Coin told the Watchdog in October 2025 that development financing was "a tricky part right now."
Pinecroft moved faster. City records list a Technical Review Committee meeting for the project on August 7, 2023, and log occupancy approvals for Collin Place addresses during 2025. Pinecroft went from review to finished homes in about two years, while the Aster Court site took most of this decade to break ground. Close to downtown, few for-sale projects have reached construction, and that scarcity is part of what buyers at Aster Court are paying for.
Timing is the other big difference between the two communities. At Pinecroft, homes are finished and you can walk through the model. At Aster Court, the project is fully funded and site work began in November 2026. Purchase agreements use spring 2028 as a conservative completion date, and the stated goal is to deliver sooner.
Prices at Aster Court are set to rise by phase. Phase 1 has six homes. In Phase 1, a private in-home elevator costs $40,000, compared with $60,000 in later phases, and Phase 2 is expected to be priced higher. For a buyer planning to stay through their later years, the elevator price is a real factor in the decision.
Ongoing costs at both communities follow a similar model. Aster Court's projected HOA dues are about $350 a month as of this fall's project materials. The HOA covers roofs, gutters, exterior surfaces, walkways, driveways, landscaping and the master insurance on the buildings. Pinecroft's HOA covers exterior maintenance, lawn care and snow removal. This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and buyers should confirm HOA figures and terms for their own situation with the right professional.
Buyers comparing these two communities are also looking at resale homes, and the resale market is moving the opposite way from Aster Court's phase pricing. The Canopy Realtor Association's October 2026 report for the City of Asheville shows 968 homes for sale, 6.5 months of supply and 69 days on market until sale for the month. In October 2026, sellers received 91.4% of their original list price, down from 93.4% in October 2025. In October, WLOS described the area as a balanced market, with longer selling times and sellers lowering asking prices.
Asheville's October 2026 median sale price was $508,000, up 21.5% from October 2025. That figure comes from only 124 closings, down from 194 a year earlier. For the year through October, the median was $497,000, down 1.6% from the same period in 2025. When fewer homes sell in a month, the median can swing on which homes happened to close. The year-to-date figure is the more reliable read: citywide prices were roughly flat, and buyers had some room to negotiate.
In that market, Pinecroft's starting price is close to the city's resale median for the year, and Pinecroft is new construction. Aster Court sits at about twice that level, and the developer expects later phases to cost more. Resale prices are flat and there's plenty of inventory. Near downtown, though, very few new for-sale homes are being built, and Aster Court's pricing reflects that.
If you're deciding between Aster Court's walk-to-downtown location and Pinecroft's extra square footage, Mills Coin & Co. can go through the Aster Court plans, Phase 1 pricing and the 2028 timeline with you at our showroom at 40 Biltmore Avenue. Schedule a private consultation and showroom visit, and see the full Aster Court details here.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
At Mills Coin & Co. Real Estate Group, we’re your trusted partner in navigating the Asheville real estate market. Whether you're buying, selling, or investing in property in Asheville, we're here to make the process smooth, seamless, and successful for you.